The Supreme Court acquitted Amoon Ayub while upholding Qaiser Ayub’s conviction, placing the attribution of digital evidence at the centre of the case
By Nasir Mehmood
ISLAMABAD: One first information report, the same broad allegation, two brothers and identical sentences from the lower courts—yet the case produced two different outcomes in the Supreme Court. Amoon Ayub was acquitted and ordered to be released after receiving the benefit of doubt, while Qaiser Ayub’s conviction was upheld. The distinction has brought a central question into sharp focus: what level of digital evidence is required to attribute disputed online material to a particular person beyond reasonable doubt?
According to the available copy of the First Information Report (FIR), the case was registered on June 9, 2011, at City Police Station Talagang in Chakwal district. The First Information Report (FIR No. 105 records the alleged occurrence as having taken place in August 2010, leaving a gap of about ten months before the formal registration of the case. The Supreme Court later accepted the explanation for the delay, observing that an initial complaint had already been made but that the internet-related nature of the allegations required engagement with the local police, the Federal Investigation Agency and questions of technical jurisdiction.
The supplied copy of the FIR appears to list only Section 295-C of the Pakistan Penal Code in the relevant offence column. The later Lahore High Court judgment, however, refers to Sections 295-A, 295-B and 295-C in connection with the prosecution. The difference is significant. Establishing when and through what legal step the additional provisions became part of the case would require examination of the complete police challan and trial-court record.
The complainant alleged that objectionable religious material had been published on a website and an associated WordPress blog. The FIR referred to Qaiser Ayub and Amoon Ayub by name and also cited the website and certain contact details. An FIR, however, is an initial record of an allegation rather than a final determination of guilt. Where a person’s name or telephone number appears on a webpage, investigators must still establish who entered that information, who controlled the relevant account and who actually created or uploaded the material.
Qaiser Ayub was arrested in November 2014. According to the prosecution, computers, laptops, hard drives, compact discs and other digital devices were recovered from an office on his identification. Amoon Ayub was arrested in April 2015, and the prosecution also claimed the recovery of a Dell laptop from the home of his father-in-law.
On December 13, 2018, an additional sessions judge in Talagang convicted both brothers under Section 295-C and sentenced them to death. Each was also fined Rs100,000. The brothers appealed to the Rawalpindi Bench of the Lahore High Court, but on June 8, 2022, the court maintained the trial-court judgment.
The High Court treated the recovered devices, forensic findings, domain-related records and information displayed on online pages as important links connecting the accused to the material. The defence argued that no eyewitness had seen either brother write or upload the disputed content; that the actual administrators of the WordPress platform were not investigated; that the principal website and the WordPress blog were separate platforms; and that the attribution and chain of custody of the digital material were open to challenge.
When the Supreme Court decided the matter on October 7, 2026, it assessed the evidence against each brother separately. In Amoon Ayub’s case, the court found that an internet or landline connection, the tenancy of an office and the recovery of a laptop were not sufficient, without more evidence, to prove his personal participation. In a family or shared business setting, the court observed, a connection or office may be registered in one person’s name while being used by several people. Being the subscriber of a connection or the tenant of an office does not automatically establish criminal responsibility for every online activity conducted through it.
The testimony concerning the recovery and condition of the Dell laptop also contained ambiguities. The Supreme Court did not conclusively hold that the device had been altered, but uncertainty surrounding its condition and custody weakened the prosecution case. The court also did not exclude the possibility that a device within a family could be shared or used without one member’s knowledge. In the absence of reliable additional evidence proving Amoon Ayub’s knowledge, intent and personal participation, the court gave him the benefit of doubt, acquitted him and ordered his release.
The conclusion regarding Qaiser Ayub was different. The Supreme Court considered files found on a computer and a Lenovo laptop attributed to him, records concerning the purchase of the domain, email accounts, online administrative information and personal documents. The judgment noted that the relevant devices also contained travel, visa, financial and private correspondence associated with Qaiser Ayub. Taken together, the court considered these links sufficient to establish his control over the devices and his connection with the disputed material, and it rejected his appeal.
Advocate Abdul Hameed Rana, counsel for the two brothers, told Qadam Qadam Sach TV that Amoon Ayub had been released. He said no strong and direct evidence had been produced to connect Amoon personally with the WordPress blog or the disputed online content, and that the prosecution case against him had therefore remained weak.
Rana disputed the judicial conclusion concerning Qaiser Ayub. He said the prosecution case had been built around various files and items of information attributed to laptops and other devices, but that the defence did not regard this material as direct or conclusive proof. In his view, the presence of a file on a device, administration of a website, and the act of personally writing and uploading particular content are separate matters; a sound technical and legal link must connect them.
According to counsel, further legal remedies have been pursued for Qaiser Ayub and the defence remains hopeful that he will also obtain relief. The present legal position, however, is that the Supreme Court upheld Qaiser Ayub’s conviction. The precise nature and current status of any review petition or other post-judgment proceeding would require independent confirmation from the relevant petition or court order. Any expectation of release must therefore be described as the defence’s position, not as a completed judicial outcome.
United Nations special experts also expressed concerns about the case and the fairness of the proceedings in a communication sent to the Pakistani government in September 2025. Their concerns included the absence of direct identification of the person who created the website or blog, the lack of requested information from WordPress and the question of whether contact details alone could establish that a person was the publisher of the content. These were concerns raised by UN experts, not findings of a Pakistani court.
The case of Qaiser Ayub and Amoon Ayub illustrates the difficulty of assigning criminal responsibility in the digital age. A name, telephone number, internet connection, office or laptop may constitute relevant evidence, but the decisive questions remain: who created the specific content, from which account was it uploaded, who had custody and control of the device, and what evidence establishes the accused person’s knowledge and intent?
The Supreme Court found that evidentiary chain incomplete in Amoon Ayub’s case, while it regarded the cumulative record against Qaiser Ayub as sufficient. The defence continues to challenge the strength of the digital attribution in Qaiser’s case. Responsible reporting on this sensitive matter therefore requires a clear distinction between the prosecution’s allegations, the defence’s objections and the courts’ findings—and requires that no claim be presented as more conclusive than its actual legal status.
NOTE:
The allegedly objectionable words have deliberately not been reproduced. This article is based on the available First Information Police Report registered, court records and an interview with defence counsel.

